.

Georgia Charter Schools and the Families who Need Them

Conflict over the vote in Georgia on approving charter schools is increasing as the impact on families depends on a ballot question.

When you listen to the stories of the moms and dads whose children desperately need school choice, you get a glimpse of the passion that fuels the school choice movement. As a parent, there is nothing more gut-wrenching than to watch your child suffer anguish everyday in a school that does not meet his or her needs. So what options are available when school is mandated based on a zip code, and options are denied those who may not have the bank account to afford private schooling?

Public charter schools have been an effective option for families in Georgia. They receive more flexibility and autonomy in exchange for more accountability: perform or else be closed. Recent CRCT results indicate the successes of public charter schools in our state, particularly independent or start-up charter schools. For example, Drew Charter School serves a disadvantaged community in Atlanta. Students at Drew scored 12.4% higher than the district average in Reading and 27.6% higher in Math.

Another high achieving school in DeKalb, the 2-year-old Museum School of Avondale Estates, achieved 100% in Reading two years in a row. Math scores showed 97.5% meeting or exceeding standards. The list of achievements continues at public charter schools in Georgia when compared to CRCT performances at traditional public schools throughout their districts. And the longer a student remains enrolled at a charter school, the more that student's testing results improve.

But if public charter schools that are independent are so efective, why are there so few in existence in Georgia- less than 2% of total public schools? Why aren't more public charter school petitions being approved by local school boards?

Recently, the rancor has gotten so ugly in some local school board meetings in Georgia that sitting school board members have had the temerity to tell citizens to move out of the district if they need something that better fits the individualized needs of their children. Perhaps those school board members have been too busy blasting parents to notice the ongoing downturn in the housing market and high unemployment rate that makes such callous and unsolicited advice virtually impossible.

The divisiveness within the educational system has intensified as GAE, or Georgia Association of Educators, many superintendents, and certain local school board members have led the charge seeking to discredit public charter schools and to reject as many charter petitions as possible. Some students who love their public charter schools are even frightened to wear school spirit shirts in their own communities! Adults have gone too far when they have intimidated their neighbors to this extent.

Recently, an uniformed citizen wrote in a publication that "the amendment takes power from local school boards that usually listen to parental desires". No statement could be further from reality.

Instead, if one follows the money that has been contributed to the anti-Amendment One group Vote Smart!, one will find the power bases that are opposing the Charter School Amendment. Georgia Representative Edward Lindsey recently commented in the AJC on the financial backing of such opposition groups:

“This isn’t about ideology,” Lindsey says. “It’s about turf. It’s about those folks who have a vested interest, no matter how mediocre the present may be, in not changing.”

The turf in question is the power to approve charter schools — and thus how some public education funds are spent.

Thirty-four of them are current or former superintendents. That group gave more than $16,000.

Another 30 are other types of school-system administrators: area superintendents, assistant superintendents, directors of some kind or another. These folks contributed an additional $14,000.

Eleven members of various school boards around Georgia gave almost $4,000. Ten principals shelled out $2,576.

In all, almost 60 percent of the Vote SMART! donors and more than a third of its donations came from people who run our traditional public schools. That’s one bit of turf.

Then there are the professional organizations: the Professional Association of Georgia Educators, Georgia School Boards Association and Georgia School Superintendents Association. Fifteen employees of these groups donated more than $15,000.

Additionally, the funds to oppose the charter school amendment were contributed by for-profit companies that traditional public school systems hire when they outsource projects and contracts for work.

In fact, 35 people or firms who do business with traditional public schools, from attorneys and consultants to architects and contractors, have given more than $32,000....

Georgia's educational system involves money, power, politics, and bureaucracy that exerts control at the expense of Georgia's students and families. Opposing the Charter School Amendment will deny students from lower income neighborhoods or disadvantaged circumstances a school where they can thrive and succeed. The fact is that families want more educational options and freedom to choose a school that is the right fit for their son or daughter. Contrary to spurious assertions, public charter schools in Georgia serve a higher proportion of minority students than do traditional schools.

While taxpayers fund local public schools through property taxes, not one cent will go to students in a state-approved public charter school in Georgia due to legislation that outlines the new funding formula, HB 797. Local districts will hoard the windfall of tax dollars from every family that makes the choice to send their child to a different school, including the option of a public charter school. Local school boards and superintendents should be celebrating the victory they achieved during the last legislative session in demanding that all property taxes fund only certain public schools, not state-approved public charter schools.

The state of Georgia continues to spend more on education than any other state in the Southeast, yet if Georgians simply continue the status quo, then our state will continue to rank near the bottom in education nationally.

The storm that has hit the educational system in Georgia has created some strange bedfellows and contortions of logic. The entrenched education establishment is shrieking as their power and their turf are being threatened. Still, when the twister stops spinning, it should not be Georgia's students on which the house falls. Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain: the great educrats may have spoken, but the yellow brick road is paved with educational options and freedom for all.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Filtered78 October 31, 2012 at 04:59 PM
Great piece.
ITPC November 01, 2012 at 11:10 AM
Golden Triangle Tour Package -Offers golden triangle tour, Golden Triangle Tour India, India golden triangle tour packages,Delhi Agra Jaipur Tours
Michael Wakefield November 01, 2012 at 11:37 AM
There is already a state level appeal process for groups whose application for a charter school is denied. We do not need two systems. Especially when the second system that you propose is governed by people who are appointed and have no accountability to the electorate.
Rhonda Gatch November 01, 2012 at 12:00 PM
Supt. Barge has stated he will not approve ANY charter schools through state BOE until he is fully funded. GA spends $7 billion on Education, 43% of its total budget, & more than any other state in the southeast. He is fully funded now. The Charter School Commission operated successfully for years & is nothing new- it's just returning to system that existed before 2011. We have Public Charter Schools on GA & they serve GA's PUBLIC school system. It is no more a parallel or duplicate system than public magnet schools or alternative schools are. The monopoly on structuring schools that fail must be broken to provide successful options for students & families.
Michael Wakefield November 01, 2012 at 12:20 PM
What will you do when your new precious appointees fail to do your bidding, ask for another constitutional amendment?
Tim November 01, 2012 at 01:16 PM
The slanted way the ammendment is written is justification enough to vote no. Until our elected officials start acting like adults and presenting these fairly and non-biased, we need to send a message that we won't vote for them.
Rhonda Gatch November 01, 2012 at 01:33 PM
The people will decide by direct vote on the ballot question. Greatly weakening GA's school choices hurts students & families. Competition to the current monopoly is necessary for GA. Coming in near the bottom in education is not okay. 67% graduation rate, 1 in 3 students dropping out, is not okay. Independent, start up public charter schools must originate in the local community w/ parents & business leaders designing the curriculum & running the school as a nonprofit. These school return power to parents & the local community. & out of the control of bureaucracy & red tape. The people of GA will decide!
Maureen Upchurch November 01, 2012 at 06:06 PM
Charter schools are a vital and necessary part of the education system in our state and country. They add to the checks and balances of the current education system AND they provide top-notch education to its students. My son was in a charter school in NC befor we moed to Georgia. The teachers were motivated, the administration engaged and the students from all socio-economic backgrounds were challenged and excited to learn. In many ways, I feel that education of the stakeholders - parents and teachers alike - on what exactly a charter school IS is vital. I knew educators - principals in fact - who were against charter schools and knew nothing about them. If you believe in state-funded education, this is a powerful alternative to the heavily burdened education system, especially in our lower-income regions. Charter schools are funded by the state and run by private institutions. Learn about these programs and take a chance, if you are not convinced. You will not be disappointed!!
Midtwnguy November 01, 2012 at 09:57 PM
We have a locally approved charter school in my county. Those who are funding the pro are out of state companies who will reap the reward that higher funded charters will recieve from state and local funds without any local oversight by localy elected boards. Fully fund local schools before establishing a new level of state and locally funded private schools!
Michael Wakefield November 02, 2012 at 12:49 AM
The money of the special interests will decide!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something